The Hall Dog

I Scream won’t name a hot dog after just anyone, but when you come up with something like this, it deserves a spot on the menu.

Introducing the soon-to-be-famous Hall Dog.

Forrest Hall, from Low Key Watersports,  likes his weenie with Reese’s Peanut Butter sauce, barbeque sauce and relish. The Hall Dog. $4.50.

(Is it just us, or is Forrest the spitting image of Orlando Bloom as that archer elf dude, Legolas,  in the Lord of the Rings?)

21 Responses to “The Hall Dog”

  1. Bill Hoffman
    February 24th, 2010 06:47
    1

    I think he has spent too much time under water!

  2. Steph - NH
    February 24th, 2010 07:10
    2

    Well, our favorite sandwich as kids came from my Grampa…peanut butter and dill pickles! Never thought of adding the hot dog, but why not? Go Forest!

  3. Carib Mark
    February 24th, 2010 07:24
    3

    Your Mom would tell you that you shouldn’t dive, let alone go IN the water for at LEAST 2 hours after one of these! And even then, don’t swim too close behind Hall. Ha ha!

  4. Lynn Blaisdell
    February 24th, 2010 07:38
    4

    EWWWW!!

  5. Rob
    February 24th, 2010 08:27
    5

    I promise you that if I showed my wife this, she’d vomit and then go on a riotous rage throughout the Mid-Atlantic seaboard. She’s serious about her hotdogs and this is unacceptable.

    Can’t we get someone to ship down a cart and a few gallons of dirty water from NYC? Set up at the ferry dock…

  6. Carrianne
    February 24th, 2010 08:41
    6

    It must have been one heck of a late night munchie session that inspired this concoction!

  7. Nancy B
    February 24th, 2010 09:11
    7

    He totally is the guy from the Lord of the Rings – I think it every time I see him :)

  8. Pirate Rob
    February 24th, 2010 09:13
    8

    What? No jelly? You call that a hotdog? -PR

  9. Marcia
    February 24th, 2010 09:49
    9

    That sounds positively disgusting.

  10. aroobagirl
    February 24th, 2010 10:18
    10

    Mustard and sauerkraut, period. Why ruin a good thing?

  11. Pete (Mr. Marcia)
    February 24th, 2010 10:39
    11

    Chicago dog or nothing…vienna all-beef dog; Rosen’s poppy seed bun; mustard; onion; bright green relish; pickle slice; tomato wedges and a few sport peppers.

    Okay, chili-cheese dogs don’t suck either.

  12. zen
    February 24th, 2010 10:59
    12

    sorry dude, that is effing disgusting! But to each their own. =)
    Cheers!

  13. Panky
    February 24th, 2010 12:55
    13

    Peanut butter on a hotdog ?? That’s as bad as fruit in beer……

  14. Elizabeth
    February 24th, 2010 14:25
    14

    $4.50 for a hotdog? Wow.

  15. Ruth
    February 24th, 2010 17:14
    15

    Maybe I’m just used to living on an island where rents are really high and everything we consume is shipped in from somewhere else, but I don’t think $4.50 for a hot dog on St. John is bad at all!

  16. The Factor
    February 24th, 2010 19:00
    16

    “You got peanut butter on my hotdog!” “No, you got hotdog on my peanut butter!”

  17. Debbie
    February 24th, 2010 21:52
    17

    GROSS!!! I saw this this morning but was too grossed out to write about it.

    I’m glad others think the same way. I think you should keep track of how popular it becomes and let us know.

    Happy Wednesday – expecting 6-18 inches of snow starting tonight.

  18. Gary
    February 25th, 2010 08:52
    18

    I have to agree with Ruth. The price is not outrageous but I could certainly do without the peanut butter. However, I love peanut butter and horseradish on saltines. Sounds gross doesn’t it? Give it a try and you’ll be hooked too!

  19. Ruth
    February 26th, 2010 12:27
    19

    I did it. I had a Hall Dog for lunch.
    It was great!

  20. Gary
    February 26th, 2010 20:26
    20

    You go Ruth!!

  21. Tom Harris
    February 26th, 2010 23:12
    21

    Oh please. Dude can eat what he wants. I might try it but not sure. But still Forrest, rock on. That’s cool.

Leave a Reply

Advertisements

Ceremonies St. John

Ceremonies St. John

"Wedding planning exclusively on St. John"

Annie Caswell

Annie Caswell

"Kissed by Fire Creations"

VI Ecotours

VI Ecotours

"Guided kayak, hike and snorkel tours"

Courtesy Car Rentals

Courtesy Car Rentals

"Prompt, friendly, affordable."

The Jolly Dog

The Jolly Dog

"At Skinny Legs"

Cruzin Away

Cruzin Away

"Island hopping, snorkeling or fishing. Or, all three!"

Cruz Bay Watersports

Cruz Bay Watersports

"All things watersports!"

Island Getaways

Island Getaways

"Unforgettable vacations since 1996!"

Cruz Bay Realty

Cruz Bay Realty

"Family owned since 1985"

ClassifiedVI.com

ClassifiedVI.com

"It's easy!"

St. Johnimals

St. Johnimals

"Island Pet Outfitter"

Caravan Gallery

Caravan Gallery

"A Global Collection of Exotic Gifts and Jewlery"

Noah

Noah's Little Arks

"Yellow boats are cool"

Carefree Getaways

Carefree Getaways

"Ask about their Villa Tours DVD"

Palm Tree Charters

Palm Tree Charters

"You choose the cruise!"

Island Treasure Map

Island Treasure Map

"Grab a map, win a trip back"

Wet Woody

Wet Woody's

"A Captain, a First Mate and lots of fun!"

Mongoose Junction

Mongoose Junction

"Elegant shopping in a tropical setting!"

St. John Spice

St. John Spice

"Spices, hot sauces, more!"

Shop "Island Style"

Shop "Island Style"

"On Island or Online"

High Tide

High Tide

"Great Food, Live Music, On the Beach "

Freebird Creations

Freebird Creations

"Something for Everyone! "

Ditleff Point

Ditleff Point

"Waterfront Estates"

The Tap Room

The Tap Room

"Cold beer, cool place!"

Bongo Bongo

Bongo Bongo

"St. John's most over-exposed villa"

Bougainvillea

Bougainvillea

"Offering only the finest in tropical clothing"

R&I PATTON goldsmithing

R&I PATTON goldsmithing

"St. John's original goldsmiths - since 1973"

Destination St. John

Destination St. John

"Be treated like a VIP!"

Grande Bay Fractional Ownership

Grande Bay Fractional Ownership

"Own a piece of paradise."

Lion in da

Lion in da' Sun

"Get out on the water!"