St. John’s Best Rum Punch

Who serves the best rum punch on St. John?

After two months of research, we’ve picked our favorite. Click below to find out!

11 Responses to “St. John’s Best Rum Punch”

  1. Bob Keib
    October 24th, 2011 05:52
    1

    What would the chances be that the bartenders would be willing to publish their recipes for those of us that are starting to face the pending winter?

  2. Carol
    October 24th, 2011 06:05
    2

    Haven’t had a rum punch in either of those places. Looks like that means another trip to St. John so I can judge for myself.

  3. J. Lowe
    October 24th, 2011 08:10
    3

    Excellent research, important information, thank you for elminating all the leg work, your contribution is invaluable and we will appreciate all of your hard work while enjoying a rum punch at High Tide! Be there in 5 days!!!!

  4. J. Lowe
    October 24th, 2011 08:11
    4

    oops typo, I meant eliminating

  5. Kevin
    October 24th, 2011 08:56
    5

    Yes … pain killers, then bushwackers, then BBC’s, then … lots of hard work ahead boys. Stay hydrated.

  6. SteveV
    October 24th, 2011 09:01
    6

    Maybe the winner should be invited to the next Villa Vittles as Guest Celebrity Judge? So what meal would go best with her rum punch?

  7. Caribert
    October 24th, 2011 09:06
    7

    PainKillers next? Looks like you better get a tripod for that video camera, guys! Bobbing and weaving and video taping don’t always go together. :)

    Looks like I know where I’m going when i get on Island next time……Good choioce on the Rum Punch.

    -Bert

  8. Pinky
    October 24th, 2011 11:13
    8

    Congrats to High Tide! I totally agree with ya on this one! I have a rum punch from High Tide every time we visit! Cheers! :)

  9. SOonthebeach
    October 24th, 2011 22:50
    9

    Wow, I just got really thirsty… good thing we’ll be there a week from tomorrow!

    YES_ painkillers next please!!

    Is it ridiculous that I got really excited and butterflies in my stomach watching the announcement? Is that sad? Or do I just need some rum punch right now?

  10. SteveV
    October 24th, 2011 23:42
    10

    Better listen to Caribert…never heard of anyone getting arrested for “VWI”-Videoing While Intoxicated- but there is always a first time! If you need a designated cameraman, let me know… I know a guy…

  11. TomH
    October 29th, 2011 12:11
    11

    Be there next week. Will try them all!

Leave a Reply

Advertisements

VI Ecotours

VI Ecotours

"Guided kayak, hike and snorkel tours"

Ceremonies St. John

Ceremonies St. John

"Wedding planning exclusively on St. John"

Pilates on St John

Pilates on St John

"Goup, Private or In-Villa Instructions"

Ditleff Point

Ditleff Point

"Waterfront Estates"

Caravan Gallery

Caravan Gallery

"A Global Collection of Exotic Gifts and Jewlery"

Bougainvillea

Bougainvillea

"Offering only the finest in tropical clothing"

The Jolly Dog

The Jolly Dog

"At Skinny Legs"

Cruzin Away

Cruzin Away

"Island hopping, snorkeling or fishing. Or, all three!"

Destination St. John

Destination St. John

"Be treated like a VIP!"

Grande Bay Fractional Ownership

Grande Bay Fractional Ownership

"Own a piece of paradise."

Island Treasure Map

Island Treasure Map

"Grab a map, win a trip back"

St. John Spice

St. John Spice

"Spices, hot sauces, more!"

Diamonds International

Diamonds International

"#1 in diamond jewelry since 1988"

St. Johnimals

St. Johnimals

"Island Pet Outfitter"

Cruz Bay Realty

Cruz Bay Realty

"Family owned since 1985"

Lion in da

Lion in da' Sun

"Get out on the water!"

Copeland Boat Charters

Copeland Boat Charters

"Relax on the Water With a Private Charter"

High Tide

High Tide

"Great Food, Live Music, On the Beach "

The Tap Room

The Tap Room

"Cold beer, cool place!"

Carefree Getaways

Carefree Getaways

"Ask about their Villa Tours DVD"

Bongo Bongo

Bongo Bongo

"St. John's most over-exposed villa"

R&I PATTON goldsmithing

R&I PATTON goldsmithing

"St. John's original goldsmiths - since 1973"

Shop "Island Style"

Shop "Island Style"

"On Island or Online"

Mongoose Junction

Mongoose Junction

"Elegant shopping in a tropical setting!"

Palm Tree Charters

Palm Tree Charters

"You choose the cruise!"

Annie Caswell

Annie Caswell

"Kissed by Fire Creations"

Freebird Creations

Freebird Creations

"Something for Everyone! "

Island Getaways

Island Getaways

"Unforgettable vacations since 1996!"

Wet Woody

Wet Woody's

"A Captain, a First Mate and lots of fun!"

Noah

Noah's Little Arks

"Yellow boats are cool"

Cruz Bay Watersports

Cruz Bay Watersports

"All things watersports!"

ClassifiedVI.com

ClassifiedVI.com

"It's easy!"

Courtesy Car Rentals

Courtesy Car Rentals

"Prompt, friendly, affordable."